Comparison
FromScratch vs Base44: Test Both Side by Side
A feature list can go out of date quickly, so this guide shows how to run the same prompt through FromScratch and Base44 and score the results yourself. You finish with a verdict based on your own app.
If you are deciding between FromScratch and Base44, the most reliable answer comes from building the same app in both and judging the results yourself. Feature lists go out of date quickly, and a fair comparison depends on the app you need. This guide gives you a repeatable side-by-side method, with FromScratch used as the worked example, so you finish with your own scores rather than someone else's verdict.
Why compare FromScratch and Base44 with a test, not a feature list
AI app builders change often. A comparison table written last quarter may already be wrong about which features exist, what a plan includes, or how the builder handles a long chat. A test you run this week reflects the tool as it is today.
Before you start, write down three things:
- The app you want. A simple booking form, an internal tool, or a product catalog each stress a builder differently.
- Your budget. Check the current plans on each vendor's official pricing page. Don't rely on secondhand numbers, including the ones in this article.
- How much you will edit later. If you expect to add pages, fields and logins for months, editability matters more than a fast first draft.
This guide gives you a method and criteria. It does not declare a winner. Where it describes Base44, check the details on Base44's own site, because that is the only reliable source for its current features.
What FromScratch does, in plain terms
FromScratch is an AI app builder for people who don't write code. You describe the app in a chat, and an AI agent builds it with three parts:
- a React front-end, the part people see and click
- a Python (FastAPI) back-end, the logic that processes requests
- a database, where the data is stored
A live preview appears within minutes. You then refine the app by chatting, for example "add a search bar" or "require login." You can also attach PDFs, images and spreadsheets so the app uses your real content, such as a price list or a menu.
When the preview works, you can publish it to a public URL or to your own custom domain. Every change is saved as a version, so you can restore an earlier one if a change goes wrong. FromScratch has a free plan to start, and paid plans add credits and projects. For the current details, see the pricing page.
If you are new to this category, What is an AI app builder explains the basics before you run the test.
Set up a fair side-by-side test
A fair test uses the same conditions for both tools. Follow these steps:
- Pick one small app with a clear end state. A booking form with a staff view is a good choice. It has forms, data storage, a list of records and a login, so it exposes weaknesses quickly.
- Write one prompt and reuse it word for word. Changing the wording between tools makes the comparison meaningless.
- Time each step. Note how long you wait for the first preview and how many prompts you need before the app is usable.
- Score both tools on the same criteria. Use a simple sheet like the one below.
Write one prompt and use it in both tools
Use the prompt in the Build it with FromScratch section. Paste it into each builder without edits. Save both outputs with screenshots and dates, since you will compare them later.
Create a scoring sheet
| Criterion | What to check | Score (1–5) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-build accuracy | Do fields, labels and pages match the prompt? | ||
| Editability | How easy is it to change one thing without breaking others? | ||
| Login support | Can you require a login for the staff page? | ||
| Regressions | Do earlier features still work after each change? | ||
| Recovery | Can you restore an earlier version? | ||
| Publishing | Does a public URL work on mobile? | ||
| Ownership and exports | What do the terms say about your data? | ||
| Time to usable preview | Minutes and prompts needed |
Filling in the notes column matters more than the scores. A note like "the staff page needed three prompts to add cancellation" is evidence you can use later.
Test 1: first build from one prompt
Start with the first result, before any refinement.
- Record what each tool produced. Take screenshots of the booking page and the staff page.
- Check the layout against your prompt. The prompt asks for a service picker, a stylist picker, a time-slot picker, a name field, a phone field, a staff page behind a login and a contact section with an address. Mark each item as present, partly present or missing.
- Note what is missing and how hard it is to add. A missing feature is not a fatal problem if one follow-up message fixes it. Record the number of messages it took.
Keep your judgment fair. A tool that produces a more polished layout but drops the staff login should not score higher than one with a plainer design that includes every requested part.
Test 2: refine by chatting and check for regressions
A first build is only the start. Most of the work happens in follow-up chats.
Ask each tool for three small changes:
- Add a search bar to the staff page so the owner can find a booking by name.
- Add a new field for the customer's preferred contact method.
- Make sure the staff page requires a login.
After each change, check the earlier features. Can customers still pick a service and a time? Does the booking still save? This is where regressions show up, and they are often more important than the first build.
FromScratch saves every change as a version, so you can test recovery directly. Make one deliberately bad change, such as a broken label or a removed field, then restore the earlier version and confirm the app returns to its previous state. Write down how long that took and whether anything else was affected.
Then repeat the same three steps in the other tool. Compare the effort: the number of prompts, the time, and how many earlier features broke along the way.
Test 3: publishing, domains and what you own
A preview that only you can see is not a finished app. Test publishing with the same care.
- Publish a preview to a public URL. Open it on a phone and check that the forms are usable with a thumb, not just on a laptop.
- Connect a custom domain if you plan to use one. FromScratch supports custom domains. Check how the other tool handles this, and whether the steps are documented on its official site.
- Read each tool's terms before you commit. Look for what the terms say about your data, your right to export your code or content, and what happens to your app if you cancel. Do this on the vendors' own sites, not in a summary.
- Confirm which features need a paid plan. Check the official pricing pages for each builder. Features like additional projects or credits can change, so verify them on the day you decide.
Publishing is also where the difference between a demo and a real tool becomes clear. If you plan to take bookings from real customers, test a publish-and-share cycle end to end, including the confirmation step a customer sees.
For a broader view of how to pick a builder for non-coding work, read Best AI App Builder: How to Choose One Without Coding.
Build it with FromScratch
Follow these steps to run the first test on FromScratch. Keep your scoring sheet open.
- Create a free account and open a new project. Use the free plan to start. You do not need a credit card to try the first build, but check the pricing page for what each plan includes.
- Paste the prompt below into the chat, unchanged. Send it once and wait for the first build.
- Wait for the live preview. Note how long it took. Open the booking page and the staff page separately.
- Score the first build. Fill in the first-build accuracy row and note anything missing.
- Refine with two or three follow-up chats. Use the three changes from Test 2. After each one, check the earlier features.
- Test version restore. Make one deliberate mistake, restore the earlier version, and confirm it worked.
- Publish the preview. Check the public URL on a phone and record any problems.
- Compare with your other tool. Use your scores and notes to decide. If you want a second look at the category before you commit, FromScratch vs Lovable vs Bolt walks through another comparison.
Here is the prompt to type into FromScratch for your first test:
Build a booking app for a small hair salon. Customers pick a service, a stylist and an open time slot, then enter their name and phone number. Add a staff page behind a login where the owner can see and cancel bookings, and include a short contact section with the salon's address.
If you want to see what a complete build of this kind looks like before you start, Build a booking app with AI shows the same type of project from start to finish.
FAQ
Is FromScratch better than Base44?
It depends on the app you need, your budget and how much you plan to edit later. Run the same prompt in both tools and score the results on the same criteria. The scores will tell you more than any general claim.
Do I need to code to use FromScratch?
No. You describe the app in plain language and refine it by chatting. You will still want to understand your data and your publishing choices, such as which information customers can see, but you do not need to write code.
Can I import an existing store into FromScratch?
Yes. FromScratch can import products from an existing Shopify or WooCommerce store, and it supports e-commerce stores with a catalog, cart and checkout. Check the product details on the site before you rely on a specific workflow, since the steps may change.
Can I change my app after publishing?
Yes. You can keep chatting to change the app after it is live, and every change is saved as a version. If a change causes a problem, you can restore an earlier version. Test this on a copy first when the app handles real bookings or customer data.